Dad, Family, mission impostible

The List

I really don’t want to talk about this anymore.  Is exhausting.  But I can’t let the last post stand without adding this other piece.  Although I didn’t appreciate his parenting style, my father was an overwhelmingly awesome personal role model.   It’s very confusing to be so pissed at someone you admire terribly.

My dad is unfailingly honest.  You can set your watch by his word.  He does what he believes is right and good, even if it causes him harm.  He is courageous and thoughtful and protective.

He is the only person in my life who ever told me to be unabashedly who I was and to disregard any person, himself included, who disapproved.    All my other relationships have been tempered with that nurture/relationship oriented ‘be who you are, but first do no harm’.

In a way, he was the most generous of all my relationships, because he was adamant that I not worry for him in the equation of understanding who I wanted to be.  I have put this idea to the test several times, and he is unfailingly solid in his belief, proud even if who I am is to his detriment or against his beliefs.

Of course, I am hardly ever able to pull it off in my everyday life, and he is perpetually offended at my inability to be bold and daring, my over-concern about how others might react, and my apparent shame in who I am, forever hiding my identity on nameless blogs and refusing to let anybody I know read what I write.  He doesn’t give a damn about what other people think, and he cannot comprehend why I would.

It is a strange but comforting feeling to know that although he might be hurt by the content of my last post, he would be proud of me for saying it, and for not knuckling under in an effort to save his feelings.

I also have to tell you that there was a time  I was deeply ashamed of something I had done.  It was during a period in my life I might talk to my dad once every three months or so, long-distance.  I never told him.  To the best of my knowledge,  I didn’t even hint that there was anything wrong.

One day, out of the blue, my father sent me a letter detailing about ten big mistakes he had made in his life.  I mean, these were the kind most people take to the grave.  Some of the things I had heard sideways from my mom or aunt.  Some of them I had never suspected and probably would have lived my whole life without finding out.  They were listed, with no coyness or explanation or attempt to justify them.  He didn’t mention if he suspected I had a big secret too, and he didn’t ask.  I don’t know why, of all the amazing things he’s done for me, this is the one that I wanted to tell you, but there it is.   It was a place in my life that I felt incredibly alone, and he was the person who, precisely because of who he was, was able to blow right through all my defenses and comfort me.

I am a person who is terrified of people seeing me make a mistake, or doing something wrong.  I live in perpetual fear that someone will pull back the curtain and reveal me as undeserving of whatever kudos I have accumulated.  And here is this person, the giant of my childhood, laying bare in front of me, all the things I would cripple myself not to reveal to another soul.  He did that and never once flinched or asked for anything in return or even made a big deal about what he had done.  Every time I think about that letter, it takes my breath away.  Without his influence, I would never have written anything.  Hell, even with his influence, it took until I was in my thirties to get my nerve up.

**

So.  Thank you for your comments on the last post.  Thank you Bess, thank you Amazonite, thank you Caitlin, thank you MidLyfeMama, thank you C, thank you bon, thank you Alchemilla, thank you amy, thank you Bon, thank you breakableheart.  Your comments are full of onions and most times I have to close them, half-read, and walk away from the computer so I don’t sob right there at nap time.  I am working through them slowly, trying to use their goodness and perspective.  I am so grateful.  It is very helpful when you see my flaws in logic.  What a funny thing that it is so solid in my head, but when you point it out, it falls apart like toilet paper in the rain.  You make it so I can think through things in a different way.

11 thoughts on The List

  1. Oh, Anne. I wish I could find the right words to bring you comfort. I love the idea of The List – and I think that I may use it myself for my own children when I suspect they are struggling.

    I wish, too, that you could see how much I (and others, no doubt) admire you, your candor, your humor, and your writing. Regardless of your fears and your worries, you shine through marvelously in your words.

    Sending non-stalkery love, hugs and comfort to you.

  2. I am pretty funny in RL, but not so much when I write… occasionally amusing, but not gut-laugh funny. Times like this that I wish my face to face humor would translate. I would give anything to make you laugh right now. A great big, healing hee-haw-wet-yer-pants laugh so you could breathe better for a while.

    ah… well.

  3. Oh, gosh. I can’t imagine how anything I wrote could have helped even an iota, I was feeling pretty bleedy when I commented on your post (currently my husband and I are going through aging-parental issues x 3). Somehow, though, it’s always the daddy declining that cuts the daughter down to quivering jelly. I’m having such a hard time seeing my own dad struggle with his health, and thank heavens he isn’t having the dementia issues both my husband’s parents are immersed in… I wish you blessings and peace.

  4. Anne.
    I have been contemplating how to comment on either post. What I want so badly to tell you? Is that I loved and hated my father. He was a good man and a bad man. A good dad and a bad dad. At the end of it I wish I’d had more time to say goodbye to him, and I’m glad you have this messy, complicated time with your own dad. May you find some strange peace in all of it, even if it’s peace a decade away. We cannot choose these people, but they chose us. I am thankful for my life, and I am thankful I had a father who loved me. It was the one thing about him that I know remained even though he destroyed everything else.
    Bless you friend. xo

  5. I.
    I never thought anyone knew what I was going through until I read your blog. How do I resist and love at the same time? Why the freak did I inherit the cocoon and not the wings? Hang in there . . .

  6. *standing outside your window playing the Looney Tunes theme song*

    You know I love you, girl. Sorry I missed your last post but I will catch up and send all my heartfelt love.

    It’s hard to love so much it hurts.

  7. Oh, Anne, you are amazing. I love your honesty and thoughtfulness and willingness to look at the things you don’t like.

    I’m blown away by how much love your dad’s shown you with this kind of thing.

    My father in law’s a total pain in the ass sometimes, loves his family dearly but the way he expresses it can be *horrendous* (has a temper and also fusses horribly over the stupidest things). It’s really challenging/interesting to see the place where what someone feels and their behaviour intersect. If I only had to deal with his intentions instead of his behaviour I’d find him much easier to cope with, because he genuinely loves everyone and genuinely helps a lot. I realise this is only tangentially related to your issues, I’m just babbling. 🙂

    I’m really glad that you write.

  8. Just sending a note to see if you’re ok. Silence is healthy, and sometimes it is also disquieting. I hope all is well.

Comments are closed.